1996

The Schools We Need

1796 claims
511 evidence
266 counter-args
274 arg chains
9 chapters
Hirsch argues that despite the nation's political and economic strengths, American K-12 education is among the least effective in the developed world due to its adherence to 'naturalistic fallacies...
116 claims 27 conclusions 37 evidence All claims →
Chapter 2 argues that a shared body of knowledge is not merely a pedagogical preference but a foundational civil right and a prerequisite for democracy. The author contends that intellectual capita...
193 claims 46 conclusions 64 evidence All claims →
The educational establishment maintains a 'fortress' of progressive orthodoxy by presenting its hundred-year-old anti-subject-matter ideology as a new 'reform.' Despite dominating teacher training ...
138 claims 35 conclusions 44 evidence All claims →
Chapter 4 argues that American education is controlled by an insulated 'Thoughtworld'—a progressive ideological consensus that makes traditional pedagogical ideas literally unthinkable. Hirsch asse...
377 claims 90 conclusions 107 evidence All claims →
The author argues that educational improvement must be guided by disinterested, mainstream research rather than the selective use of science to support ideological positions. He asserts that the de...
301 claims 73 conclusions 82 evidence All claims →
The author argues that the current campaign against objective testing is a misguided extension of Romantic progressivism that undermines educational excellence and social equity. While acknowledgin...
223 claims 62 conclusions 60 evidence All claims →
This chapter synthesizes the book's core argument that the failure of American education stems from an ideological adherence to Romantic-progressive ideas which contradict empirical reality. To res...
190 claims 47 conclusions 49 evidence All claims →
The introduction to the glossary argues that the American educational 'Thoughtworld' maintains dominance through a uniform system of rhetoric and slogans that lack scientific substance. These terms...
239 claims 64 conclusions 63 evidence All claims →
In this introduction to the paperback edition, Hirsch argues that a decade of progress has shifted the national mood toward accepting content-rich curricula, evidenced by the growth of the Core Kno...
19 claims 4 conclusions 5 evidence All claims →

Arguments from this book that also appear in other books:

See all cross-book arguments →