2020

How to Educate a Citizen

868 claims
240 evidence
132 counter-args
137 arg chains
10 chapters
Chapter 1 argues that the American public education system's abandonment of a shared knowledge curriculum in favor of child-centered, skills-based 'progressive' pedagogy has eroded national cohesio...
127 claims 36 conclusions 37 evidence All claims →
Chapter 2 examines the practical implementation of child-centered education in American classrooms, arguing that its focus on natural development and content-free standards has resulted in a disjoi...
111 claims 24 conclusions 33 evidence All claims →
Chapter 3 illustrates the practical success of shared-knowledge schools by contrasting their communal instructional methods with the prevailing child-centered doctrines of American education. Throu...
98 claims 24 conclusions 29 evidence All claims →
Chapter 4 argues that the failure of American education stems from teacher-training institutes which have prioritized 'romantic' ideology over empirical cognitive science. Hirsch contends these sch...
113 claims 26 conclusions 33 evidence All claims →
Chapter 5 argues against the biological-determinist view of child development, asserting that the human mind lacks an inborn blueprint and instead functions as a 'blank slate' shaped by culture. Hi...
123 claims 30 conclusions 30 evidence All claims →
Chapter 6 argues that international evidence from the PISA assessments demonstrates a clear causal link between a nation's choice of curriculum and its educational outcomes. By comparing the 'fall ...
43 claims 7 conclusions 11 evidence All claims →
Chapter 7 argues that a multiethnic nation requires a common educational foundation to function as a single 'people.' By examining the historical intentions of America's founders and the sociolingu...
76 claims 18 conclusions 24 evidence All claims →
While praising the intent of the Common Core State Standards, Hirsch argues that they have failed to improve student outcomes or close gaps because they lack specific, sequenced content. He propose...
80 claims 20 conclusions 19 evidence All claims →
Chapter 9 argues that patriotism and nationalism, rooted in a sense of shared 'kindness' or fraternity, are essential for social durability and evolutionary survival. The author contends that the A...
65 claims 14 conclusions 15 evidence All claims →
Change is possible through the implementation of a knowledge-coherent curriculum, as evidenced by dramatic reading gains in Sullivan County, Tennessee, and the South Bronx. However, progress is hin...
32 claims 6 conclusions 9 evidence All claims →

Arguments from this book that also appear in other books:

See all cross-book arguments →